[HPFGU-Movie] POA foreshadowing DH?

[AnitaKH]

          > spoilerish to DH

> >akh piped up:
> >I had already decided that one of [the foreshadowing scenes] was
> >Buckbeak attacking Lupin, in anticipation of his attack in book 6, but do y'all think the bridge scene with Lupin and Harry is another, even though it's really the dialogue that foreshadows 7? Maybe Cuaron asked for that scene as a pickup.
> >

  Valerie countered with:
  
I'm confused. Where does Buckbeak attack Lupin in Book 6??
   
  akh explains:
  He doesn't attack Lupin, but he comes from seemingly nowhere to attack Snape.  As soon as I read the scene in HBP, I said, "Hey, that's just like the attack in the movie!"
  
Valerie also asks:
  And how does the Lupin/Harry bridge scene foreshadow DH? [akh snipping here]
  
akh answers:
  When Lupin talks about Lily, he calls her uncommomly kind and ready to see the good in people, even, and sometimes, especially, when they couldn't see it in themselves.  (That's a major paraphrase).   Of course we presume he's talking about himself, but if it's foreshadowing something we find out later, it also applies to Snape.  She saw his potential for goodness, even as he was being lured into the DEs.  
  Mind you, I'm wide open to other ideas here.  I resisted believing the Lupin/Harry scene was foreshadowing on Curaron's part, precisely because it seemed to fit just fine with Lupin's situation, plus we know JKR gets to look at the written script.  How could she get chills from watching something she knew was in the movie?   I'm just not coming up with anything else that would be startling foreshadowing.  All suggestions welcome!
   
  akh, who should probably stick POA in her DVD and watch it again.  Beats cleaning house!
   


      Recent Activity
    
      26
  New Members

Visit Your Group 
  SPONSORED LINKS
      
   Harry potter movies  
   Harry potter movie goblet of fire  
   Harry potter  
   Harry potter book  
   Harry potter birthday party

      Yahoo! Movies
  What's Hot Now
  Check out the top
  rated movies.

    Yahoo! Search
  Try a shortcut 
  Get local weather
  faster.

    Yahoo! TV
  Love TV?
  Listings, picks
  news and gossip.



  .

 
         


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]