[HPFGU-Movie] First OotP Movie review

[Ronin_47]

--Karen Wrote--
>>>That was very interesting. The fact that someone who isn't even an 
>avid Potter fan found it enjoyable and good is extremely promising. 
>I had to laugh at how annoyed he was by Umbridge. I thought to 
>myself, that is how she was written. The character has you at a 
>heightened frustration pitch halfway (if not sooner) through the 
>book, why not the movie. So, they have probably done extremely well.<<<
 
 
 
--Ronin'sComments--
This review was discomforting to me.  It was a good review, but from a
person who thinks that JKR's writing is bad or average and who thought that
GOF was the best HP movie.
The other review that appeared was much better IMO, because it was from
someone who had actually read the books and was aware of all of the cuts
that were made in GOF, etc. He says that the film was obviously cut, but
that the important details are included and it is taken from the book,
rather than being re-written. Also, the movie was incomplete as editing and
effects still need to be completed. This was very comforting to me.
 
Cheers,
Ronin


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]