Your favorite actor/actress in HP movies

Cat CatMcNulty at comcast.net
Fri Aug 29 23:36:01 UTC 2008


--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:
<Major snippage> Carol:
> it was the whole personality. Somehow, I can't picture Michael 
Gambon saying, "Alas! Earwax!" And, asomeone else (I think it was 
zanooda)mentioned, Book!Dumbledore would never yell at Harry and 
shake him as Gambon!DD does in the GoF film. He really needs to read 
the books and play *Dumbledore* rather than playing himself as a 
bearded man in Wizard robes (of sorts).
> 
 OH! That particular scene really irritated me!!!! It was so Un-
Dumbledore! In OOTP book!Dumbledore even reacts very forcefully went 
he reprimands Delores for shaking Marietta. "Delores, I can not 
permit you to manhandle my students!" (Please excuse if this is not 
an exact quote because I do not have the book at hand.)
I am so disappointed that Gambon did not (He admitted) read the books 
in preparing for his characterization of Dumbledore.

IMHO The costuming that Harris!Dumbledore wore gave him a regal and 
stately bearing. Gambon!Dumbledore's costume makes him look like an 
unmade bed!
(Gambon looks like he wear the same costume and portray Scrooge in 
bed, confronted by the Christmas Ghosts) 

Cat
 





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive