[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Introduction

[Miley Cyrus]

Candace:
> I think Alfonso did a beautiful job. Prisoner was what made me a 
> fan of the series. Chris made them to child-like which was 
> appropriate for the first two movies. Chris is a brilliant 
> director, don't get me wrong. But he would have kept them child-
> like. And I couldn't see all those bright colors and lighting for 
> the story about a stalking convict and dementors. I don't know how 
> Alfonso would have faired with Goblet, but he would have done Order 
> perfectly I believe. And Deathly Hallows I think he would do 
> amazingly. But we are stuck (or at least I am because I don't like 
> his style) with Yates. 

   
Yes I agree.  Alfonso did a great job in HP3. He transformed HP from a kiddish movie into a more mature movie that a normal teenager would like to watch. However I was kind of disappointed that they didn't mention in the movie that Hermione and Ron were prefects in the 5th part because those who haven't read the books will never know that Dumbledore chose Hermione and Ron instead of choosing his favourite student, Harry. And some more details that I felt would look good in the movie were not included. For example-Harry going out with Cho Chang on Valetines Day and the scene in which they get into an argument and Cho starts crying again (which she does almost all the time) would have been essential to portray Harry's relationship before Ginny gets into his life. This would have been helpful for those who haven't read the book to differentiate how Ginny was far better than Cho who was no match for Harry. Anyways, even with the absence of these details HP5th is my favourite movie so far among the released HP films.
 
rithika_mileycyrus