British actors that you'd like to see in the last two films

Carol justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 7 02:16:58 UTC 2008


Carol:
> > It just occurred to me: HBP has been completely cast and Hepzibah
Smith isn't listed as a character. Surely they're not going to omit
that scene? Will DH be short one Horcrux? They *can't* snip the
Gringotts break-in, which alerts Voldemort (via Bellatrix) that a
Horcrux has been stolen. And if the cup Horcrux is essential to DH,
how can they cut it from HBP?
> 
> 
> Potioncat:
> Well, the Gaunts aren't in it either, so no ring or locket. I'm sure 
> the movie will work it out somehow. It won't have to make sense.
>
Carol:
It won't have to make sense? Why not? And there *will* be a locket, if
only a fake one, because we have the cave scene. I can see leaving out
 how the Horcruxes came into Tom Riddle's possession and even their
history (no Grey Lady in DH?) but not what they are. He has to know
that he's looking for, to quote from memory, "The locket, the cup, the
snake, and something from Gryffindor or Ravenclaw."

Carol, who supposes that the simplest way around the problem is just
to have DD tell Harry what the Founders' treasures are but would find
that very unexciting





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive