The Felix Felicis photo

[Carol]

zanooda wrote:
> 
> You are right, but this shouldn't be a problem for the movie-makers
- don't they have fat suites and expert makeup artists to change the
appearance of actors who don't have "the right build" :-)? No,
Broadbent's appearance in RL is *not* the reason why we have a
different-looking Slughorn in the movie. It's the director's "vision",
I suppose :-). Otherwise I don't see why they didn't make him look
like in the book, it wouldn't be too difficult, IMO.

Carol responds:
I agree. I don't usually like Mary Grand-Pre's drawings, but she gets
Slughorn exactly right. Duplicate this, David Yates!

http://www.hp-lexicon.info/images/chapters/hbp/c04-horace-slughorn.jpg

Carol, who really doesn't understand why the director has departed so
far from JKR's description of this essentially comic character