Rupert Grint
sartoris22
sartoris22 at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 1 17:15:42 UTC 2008
--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Nightbreed" <md at ...> wrote:
>
> Because of this you don't see Ron in many of the just Harry-Ron
scenes you
> get in the book, or Ron at home or around his brothers. I think
what happens
> is they look at certain lines and they think, well book Ron has
this, that
> and the other thing to make that line sound right but Movie Ron had
all
> those other moments cut out so he'll stay comic relief and Hermione
will say
> it.
saroris22
I've often wondered if the movie Ron influenced Rowling's writing of
the book Ron. He's an oddly static character, who doesn't seem to
grow even though he meets challenges. For example, Ron is a quidditch
winner in OOTP, yet is still an unsure quidditich player in HPB. In
some ways, it doesn't make sense. And the fact that Ron has still not
approached Hermione by the beginning of DH seems improbable. I know
that Ron has to earn Hermione's love by getting the basilik fangs and
showing compassion for elves, but he knows that he likes Hermione, so
what is he waiting for? After all, Hermione kisses him in DH. If she
hadn't kissed him, would Ron have waited forever? I suppose Rowling
had the kissing scene planned out well in advance, but I can't help
thinking that the book portrayal of Ron was somewhat effected by the
movie Ron, because he has such a weird course of development.
>
>
>
>
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive