Young Snape in HBP

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:

> Carol, who suspects that Young Severus appears in the same uncanonical
> scene or scenes as Young Lucius and Young Regulus (and I'm afraid it's
> the Slughorn memory, which would make them as old as Tom Riddle!)


zanooda:

Well, one of the scenes is from the "moving picture" - I suppose it's a 
picture in Slughorn's office, where some of Sluggy's old students (Slug 
club members?) are shown. Severus, Lucius and Regulus could all be in 
such picture. As for another, "non-picture" scene, I really can't 
imagine what this can be, but I'm sure it's *not* Sluggy's memory :-)! 
Even those movie-makers can't be *so* ignorant about the books!