Bill's injury (Re: The Problems with the DH movie)
Richard Shepard
shepardrj at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 2 04:14:55 UTC 2009
> > zanooda:
> >
> > Someone :-)? Bill will defend Fleur, of course :-). Greyback always attacks girls, right? Imagine, the DEs crash the wedding, there is a battle and Fenrir goes straight for the bride... :-).
> >
>
> Richard:
>
> Sounds like a very Hollywood-ish way to do it :)
> I bet it is something just like that. The way they protrayed Fleur in GoF would fit pretty well with her reacting like a bit of a helpless victim and require Bill to jump in front of her.
>
>
> Andie
>
> I have a question on the wedding in itself. In the book Bill met Fleur during the 3rd task at the Tri-Wizard Tournament. He got her a job at Gringotts so she can work on her English and he transferred back to England to be "near" her.
>
> In the movies - none of this happened. Bill & Molly were not at the 3rd task as Harry's family. Bill did not meet Fleur etc...
>
> I know there having a wedding but when did the bride & groom meet? How did they find each other? When did all this take place?
>
> Thanks for any help on this.
>
Richard:
It shouldn't be too hard to set the stage for the wedding with a few establishing scenes and conversations. Fleur is working at Gringotts to improve her English, whether or not Bill had anything to do with her getting the job. Bill came back to England to be near his family and the Order of the Phoenix during these dark days. He's a handsome risk taker, she's Fleur, put them together and instant chemistry :)
They will probably have been engaged the same amount of time or a little less than the book, but she obviously wasn't staying at the Burrow to bond with the family since she was not with them in any of the scenes in HBP.
More information about the HPFGU-Movie
archive