[HPFGU-Movie] Re: Finally saw it! - The Cane and the Room.

[Child Of Midian]

From: HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com [mailto:HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of Steve





And what was the deal with hiding the book. If I recall, Harry just hands
the book over to Ginny, and doesn't really hid it at all. Where is the
DIADEM? Don't we need that in the plot? Shouldn't Harry have at least seen
something vaguely crown-like in the room to lay the clue that that is the
location of the very important to the plot lost diadem of Ravenclaw.

How are they going to get around that? 
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>.

Here's your answers: In the book Harry hides the book in the room after
attacking Malfoy in the toilet when Snape demands to see his books, he then
takes Ron's book to Snape and it has Ron's name spelled funny in it because
he was using a spell-check quill from Bill and George's shop that wasn't
working.

Here's how I believe they will play it in DH, H.R.H. will battle D.C.C. in
the Room of Requirement and simply stumble across the diadem there, OR, they
will use the fact that it's become Nevilles hiding place, he will tell Harry
he saw something like what he's looking for in there.

For whatever reason they wanted Harry /  Ginny's kiss to be private and
secret and they wanted to ADD Ginny to as many scenes as possible (good
idea, since she's hardly in the book, I found the movie love-story much,
much more believable, the one improvement over the book! IMO) rather than in
the middle of the common room after the quiddich (damn! How do you people
remember how to spell these made-up words?) match that's not in the film.

 

Going to see the (again) movie tomorrow (just re-read the book in the last
48hrs) so my 10-yr old can finally see it (our 7-yr old won't go and my poor
wife has to sit through G-Force with her).

 

md



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]