SS/PS MOVIE DISCUSSION

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:
 

> Prologue: Dumbledore, McGonagall, and Hagrid leave Baby Harry at the
> Dursleys; Lily's death


zanooda:

Wasn't Lily's death shown in Diagon Alley part, when Hagrid was
telling Harry the story?



> Carol wrote:

> I can't remember whether Book!Firenze knows that the
> unicorn-blood-drinking creature is LV or not.


zanooda:

In the book he said to Bane something like "I will fight against what
is lurking in this forest" and he told Harry it was LV who wanted the
Stone, so it seems that he knew. I don't know how the centaurs found
out, because in the book it was Quirrell (with LV inside) who drank
the blood. In the movie it's more understandable, because the creature
shown there was not human, IMO (although I don't remember what
Movie!Firenze said). So it's no wonder they knew or guessed who this was.

P.S.  I wonder why Movie!Firenze looks more like Book!Bane that like
Book!Firenze :-). What was the point of changing him?