SS/PS MOVIE DISCUSSION

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Tue Feb 10 13:09:55 UTC 2009


 
> zanooda:
> 
> Nah, LOTR troll was scarier and much less human-like :-). 
> 

Potioncat:
Did anyone find the troll scene to be scary? Or scary enough? As I 
watched it this time, the whole thing was more humorous than 
frightening. Fluffy didn't seem scary either. The kids got away too 
easily. The Dark Forest with Voldy and the dungeon challenges were 
pretty tense.

Speaking of the Dark Forest, I'd forgotten about one of my favorite 
movie scenes--Flich escorting the kids to detenion. His comments and 
facial expressions break me up. However, now that we've seen Umbridge 
and DH....the "old punishments" take on a more serious note. (He's 
still funny.)

In the movie, Hagrid seems to be in detention as well as he mourns the 
loss of Norbert. DD has sent the baby dragon to a reserve. It's very 
different in the book. The changes made here, and in the pigtail scene 
make Hagrid a slightly different character.





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive