SS/PS MOVIE DISCUSSION

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:

> BTW, isn't "that spear thrust would have skewered a
> wild boar" a "goof" since the FOTR Troll doesn't use a spear?)


zanooda:

Well, the FOTR troll wields some kind of mace, right, but then,
remember, Aragorn pokes the troll in the chest with a spear, which he
(it?) yanks out and hits Frodo with it :-). In the book, of course,
Frodo is not hit by the troll, but by someone else, iirc, again with a
spear :-).


> Carol, whose image of the Fat Lady doesn't match either 
> Columbus's or Cuaron's


zanooda:

I must admit that I never thought about how Fat Lady should look:-),
but I think that her sudden change in PoA was one of those "changes
for the sake of change" that Cuaron made (Flitwick, Tom etc.).