A Modest proposal (was Harry Potter Ending)

[wildirishrose01us]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "eggplant107" <eggplant107 at ...> 
wrote:
>
> I humble propose that it would have been interesting if JKR had 
simply
> stopped writing at page 704 and the last words in the entire series 
was:
> 
> "He saw the mouth move and a flash of green light and everything was
> gone."
> 
> If she wanted to be especially naughty JKR could have included 50
> blank pages at the end of the book so the reader could feel them and
> think even when he read the above there must be more to it that 
that.
> But when the reader turned the page all he would see is:
> 
> THE END
> 
> I am certain this subversive thought must have occurred to her 
because
> the subsequent riots and blood in the streets would be most amusing.
> 
>  Eggplant

Marianne:

First of all, sorry for the non-trimming of the first post I sent.  I 
forgot.

Ok, I know I've written this somewhere on a HP list before, but I 
know a person that thought JKR took the easy way out and not killed 
Harry off in the end.  In fact more than a few people felt that way.

And yes, he would have been very amused at the riots and blood in the 
streets in reaction to the ending.

A question for Steve.  Considering the way you feel the need to argue 
with almost everything that is written, would you happen to be on a 
certain music list I'm on and your name happens to be Soren?

You write and argue just like him.

Marianne
A friend will bail you out of jail
A great friend will be sitting with you in the next cell saying
"Damn, we screwed up, but it was fun."
>