Movie Talk from OT site (was Carol's question to new Steve)

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Tue Jan 13 22:01:48 UTC 2009


 
> Carol responds:
> 
> But how would we handle the discussions? Do we need to designate
> posters to view and summarize each film and pose questions? We can't
> have chapter discussions, but we could have one per film.

Potioncat:
Well, I suppose it could be as formal as setting up designated 
individuals to summarize a movie and start off questions. With set 
dates for new discussions.

Or it could be as informal as saying everyone watch movie #____ by 
this date and let the posts begin. Sort the way we started general 
discussions after book came out.

Any elves out there with thoughts?

No, no, of course I know all the elves have thoughts---and very good 
thoughts too. Let me rephrase that. Are there any elves out there 
with any elfish thoughts about this discussion?

 
> Carol, willing to give the discussions a shot but thinking that it
> might be hard to keep "book contamination" (!!!) out of the 
summaries


Potioncat:
If we are going to summarize the movie, it should be just what we saw 
on screen, but that doesn't mean questions have to be limited to 
that. We might want to agree on whether we will worry about spoilers 
to future movies. Steve V has said he doesn't mind spoilers, but are 
there other moviefans who don't want to know what's coming?








More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive