SPOILER!!! HBP REVIEW

[*BARB*]

md wrote:
> <snip>
> All in all it's an entertaining film with deep emotional
> resonance, excellent effects, lots of Humor and excellent
> acting, but it's like 20 pounds of story in a 10 pound
> bag. A better approach truly might have been to trim these
> films to a simpler, less hurried, busy story and film the
> extra for extended Blu-Ray release later. What we get
> instead is an attempt to crowbar as much in as humanly
> possible and with an 8 month delay one would have hoped
> the parts that don't work would have been realized by
> someone and fixed. Either way this is what fans get, a
> deeper, genuine film that falls short on logic in some
> places and feels like a highlight real.


BArb:
My thoughts too....I think they spent too much time with
all the romance and left out important things in the book.
It felt uneven and if I had not read the books I would have
been lost most of the time.

They also left out them trying to find out who the half
blood prince was and its importance for the end.
 (in the book Snape wants the book from Harry and he goes
into the room of requirement to get it and then don't they
fight with Malfoy and one of his buddies dies and Harry
saves Malfoy?? it catches on fire right??)

I really missed not having the funeral, battle in the castle
and DD using the spell on Harry, your right he would have
fought them to the end to save DD.

Yea I thought Tonks found Harry in the book, why the change?

Anyway it doesn't change my love for the movie, I will love
them no matter how they transfer them from book to movie but
I do hope the last one follows the book better, wonder if JK
Rowling has to approve the script??

BArb