My Review of Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince

[eggplant107]

"Child Of Midian" <md at ...> wrote:

> I also thought Dumbledore should've been weaker
> from the poison when they got back to the Astronomy Tower.
 
Yes I agree with you, Dumbledore was a little too perky.

> I also didn't like the "You are no assassin" (or whatever he says) line. "You are not a killer" has more impact, I think.

On that I disagree, I think that small departure from the book was an improvement. 

 Eggplant