[HPFGU-Movie] The Problems with the DH movie

[Valerie Flowe]

coolbeans3131:
>  What it tells me is that they will be making DH a very, very simple 
> film.
> <snip> Snapes role in the prophecy and his relationship with Lilly 
> with simply vanish, it will
>  come down to the one memory of DD telling Snape that Harry must die by
>  Voldy's hand in the end and it will be played off as nothing more 
> than Snape
>  relaying DD last order.

Valerie: ACK!!! So how will they explain the animosity that Snape had 
towards Harry all these years?! Was he merely jealous that Harry was 
considered special as 'The boy who Lived'? No! He was in love with 
Harry's mother who was his only childhood friend. Then she dumps him 
for his arch-nemesis James, who, along with Sirius, torture him 
mercilessly! That was such an important revelation in Book 7.

coolbeans3131:
> Dobby should have brought the gilly-weed in GOF and
>  he should have been around in OOTP and HBP as an 'extra' as only a 
> single
>  line "now that he's free, Dobby works at Hogwarts" for an explanation.

Valerie: Well I heard that Kreacher, for sure, is coming back in Movie 
7. But no mention of Dobby. I just don't think it would have the same 
impact if Kreacher gets killed instead of Dobby! Even if he does cook 
and clean for him at Grimmauld Place! I'd rather have Dobby come back, 
than Kreacher.

I know that JKR fleshed out many characters in her books, but I think 
I'd rather have read of Lupin and Tonks' wedding and their cute little 
shell cottage, as I had more emotions invested in those characters than 
Bill & Fleur.

I also heard on Pottercast, from Yates, I believe it was, that it will 
be the trio in the Epilogue and not some older actors. Yay!