[HPFGU-Movie] Re: The Romance

[Child Of Midian]

From: HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com [mailto:HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com] On
Behalf Of cubfanbudwoman




What I reacted to -- and called your opinion -- is that I read your previous
comments as saying, AS ABSOLUTE FACT, that there is no way those hours were
missing, as in there was no reason in the world to consider that they might
contain something mysterious or significant. And I was trying to point out
why, for many people, it was quite reasonable to think that there was! They
were left unexplained, and it seemed like a goodly chunk of time to a lot of
us [that's where the opinion comes in, to me], so it wasn't weird or crazy
to have thought there might be some clues there in a series which, at many
levels, was a mystery.

Siriusly Snapey Susan,
who doesn't mind having her position challenged or questioned, especially
when we're trying to figure out if we're talking about things in the same or
different way, but who'd appreciate not having her words called "nonsense"

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Well, there is no way those hours are "missing" they are simply not covered
in the book. My OPINION is no such thing, it's an ABSOLUTE FACT. Sorry, but
I teach English, I teach reading, those hours are not missing. To classify
them as such there would have to be an instance of two events occurring
directly after each other but the times or dates being out-of-sync with the
amount of time it should take. 

 

For example, had she written "I grabbed him right after it happened and flew
him directly here" yet there was 21 hrs between the two events, then there's
missing hours, now there's something to go, wtf about. 

 

If people are going to argue how the book is writing with language that does
not match their argument, then that is nonsense. It would be like saying
"you don't talk so good."

 

md 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]