PoA MOVIE DISCUSSION.

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "potioncat" <willsonkmom at ...> wrote:

> I thought that only Hogwarts proper was on the map. So Hagrid's hut 
> and the forest would not show up.


zanooda:

Hogsmeade and the Shrieking Shack are not included, but the grounds and Hagrid's hut are, although the hut - only from outside. Lupin said he watched the Trio enter the hut and then come out twenty minutes later, this time together with Pettigrew.


> Potioncat wrote:

>  I'm trying to remember if TT Harry and TT Hermione were in the 
> castle at the same time as Harry and Hermione.


Well, that depends :-), if we are talking about the book - yes, but if we are talking about the movie - no. The time-turner effect is a little different in the movie. In the book, after turning the time-turner, TT Harry and Hermione found themselves in the Entrance hall, because it was where they (plus Ron) were three hours earlier. However, in the movie they stayed in the hospital wing, only as it was three hours earlier.

That's why in the book both HRH and TT Harry and Hermione were in the castle together - TT H&H were hiding in a broom cupboard in the Entrance hall while HRH were passing through the Hall under the Cloak. In the movie TT Harry and Hermione only caught up with "themselves" outside the castle.


zanooda, very happy to see her own post (about Lupin being on the train) that she wrote many hours ago and considered lost forever ... :-).