Shell Cottage scenes

[zanooda2]

--- In HPFGU-Movie at yahoogroups.com, "Carol" <justcarol67 at ...> wrote:


> I think that the writer has simply misremembered the scene 
> as involving Arthur rather than Bill.


zanooda:

That's quite possible, they do many mistakes in this magazine. Even if you look through this entire article (that's 28 pages :-), not only one page, you will find strange things like Hepzibah Smith disappearing instead of being poisoned, or Cormack McLaggen knowing that Hermione jinxed him and being angry.

 
> Carol, expecting Arthur to come through the film unscathed


zanooda:

Well, obviously, if Bill has the scars, then Arthur doesn't have them :-). BTW, I had time to think about it and I believe you are right that they won't change anything in HBP. They'll give Bill his scars in DH - how about the wedding? Maybe they want to show a real fight there, not just general confusion, like in the book. Imagine that: the DEs crash the wedding, Greyback (naturally :-)) goes straight for the bride, Bill interferes, gets mauled etc. One of the possibilities, anyway :-).