Re:New DH article (major spoiler if you haven't read the book!)

ZaraG zgirnius at yahoo.com
Thu Apr 22 21:10:29 UTC 2010


>Michelle Tague:
> I agree
but I was very upset that they showed (in the movie) that Snape was
> really a good guy in the tower scene when he shushed harry
 so much of the
> beginning/middle of the last book was the wonder and anger towards snape


Zara:
I don't get the impression Movie!Harry thought Movie!Snape was a good guy. As a result, I think it is quite possible that movie-only audience members may take Movie!Harry's view of the matter (which it seems you did).

I would also add that the beginning/middle of the last book were quite wonderful to this reader, who was pretty sure Snape was a good guy after reading HBP, which suggests a movie could also be to such a viewer.





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive