Percy Jackson (To Kemper)

[kemper]

> Cat:
> I am so sorry Kemper, that is quite unfortunate. I was absolutely enthralled and delighted by the first HP!It was my imagination appearing on the screen. 

Kemper:
I can see where the movie captured the look of the book, but it missed the feel, the tone and rang hollow for me. 

> Cat:
> I did become more jaded and disgruntled when The-Director-That-Must-Not-Be-Named, sacrificed many of the precious moments and nuances created by JKR and sets established in the first two HP films, to indulge his own ham-handed ego. It is a pity that my favorite book was made into my least favorite HP film.

Kemper:
My viewing experience differs.  :D  
So far, HBP is my preferred HP movie.  I'm hopeful the last movies will make for a more satisfying and healthier meal than the book with its tasty but empty calories.

Kemper