Finally saw it (no spoilers)

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 11 15:55:55 UTC 2011


I finally saw DH on Saturday. I couldn't find anyone to go with me, so I went alone before the showings ended. Unfortunately, I came home to find that real tragedy had struck half a mile from my home: the Safeway shootings in Tucson.

I'm still in shock and praying for Gabrielle Giffords and the others, so I'll keep my comments on the film short. I enjoyed it and thought that the actors, director, screenwriter, etc. did a good job of keeping the film understandable for those who hadn't read the books (with a few exceptions that I'll discuss later) and paving the way for DH2. They did move some scenes out of sequence but no harm done there. Yes, I noticed omissions and alterations, but I understand why most of them were made, especially simplifications like those made in the Godric's Hollow scene, which probably benefited the viewers who hadn't seen the film and certainly tightened the plot.

Carol, who will post again later when it feels more appropriate to talk about HP





More information about the HPFGU-Movie archive