Cross-cultural issues - long and rambly
dfrankis at dial.pipex.com
dfrankis at dial.pipex.com
Fri Aug 3 17:29:15 UTC 2001
--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at y..., "Tabouli" <tabouli at u...> wrote:
<much fascinating stuff in danger of getting a written bonding
response snipped>
>Anyone on the list who has interesting observations or comments
about the differences between people in different English speaking
regions, both international and intranational (e.g. Southern US vs
East Coast US, etc.), feel free to send 'em on to me! I promise
lavish acknowledgments and footnotes in my book...
>
Here's one that has puzzled me for some years - it may be the
individual concerned rather than his culture. During the former Bush
Administration we were asked to look at the prospects for a
particular aspect of East West affairs and prepare some technical
mateiral. Our (UK govt) customer also wanted an American view of the
issue, so we hired a guy who wrote a lengthy treatise.
One of the things of interest to our customer was the medium to long
term view of the issue. Our American just could not provide it. He
gave a brilliant and detailed analysis of the way the Bush
Administration worked, but when we pointed out that in a year or so
there might be a new president, and could he identify trends in
American thinking, he couldn't cope. A new president would bring his
own way of doing things, and it was impossible to say anything about
what that might be. In a conversation I remember remarking that over
time we could expect China to replace Japan as the main rival to the
US in the Far East, and he just boggled at the idea.
He defined himself culturally as a New Yorker (with increasing
frequency as he fell foul of the wingeing customer syndrome I
described in the previous post) and regarded himself as being faster
on the social uptake than others because of it (you have to, in NY,
according to him). A Catholic and a lifelong Democrat, he went back
to the States to join the Perot campaign when the Clinton/Bush choice
became clear.
I felt this did illustrate a cultural issue that (generalising
dangerously) Americans think in terms of individuals when it comes to
politics, while Europeans (and in matters like this Brits are deeply
European, whatever you might hear) think in terms of impersonal
forces and trends. So we look for alignments of interests; they for
good guys and bad guys. I wonder if the notion of the 'rogue state'
(which I as an old worlder think largely nonsense) is related?
Oops, I realise I have rambled deeply into the politics of one of the
hottest issues across the Atlantic right now.
Anyway, to change the subject rapidly to the reason this is a post
not a personal e-mail to Tabouli, is that on the main list she
mentioned the Chinese week. What is the relationship of this to the
Western (ie Middle Eastern) week? Does the Sky/Heaven/Sun day fall
on Sunday? Do they share a common origin or is it the coincidence
of conveniently chopping the month in four?
Finally, what book? and what does Fff. mean?
Oh BTW, I looked at my Lupin reference and realised it's a bad
example - Harry says You're the best DADA we've ever had and Lupin
says it's been a pleasure teaching Harry. Teach me to go On Topic
here.
David, really with too little to do at work right now
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive