Quick canon question

[Kelley]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at y..., "Amy Z" <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> Alicia was a reserve the year before Harry got there, so she was 
> probably a 2nd-year then--if you can't be on the team your first 
year, you probably can't be a reserve either. >>>>>

Excellent point, Amy.  I remembered the mention about being a 
reserve, but didn't make the age/year connection. 
 
> If this logic holds, she's at least 2 years older than Harry, a 6th 
> year (or even a 7th year) in GF. >>>>>

Yep, I'm following, makes sense.
 
> I don't think we know about either Angelina or Katie, except that 
> Angelina is 17 already in fall of GF so she's already a tad old for 
a sixth-year--it seems very unlikely that she's a fifth-year.>>>>>

Right; I took the very point that the twins were surprised she was 
old enough to enter the TWT as that she was only a sixth year.  (Why 
would they be surprised a seventh year was 17 years old, you know?)

> My guess therefore is:
> 
> In OoP Katie could be 6th or 7th
> Angelina and Alicia probably 7th
> Fred and George 7th
> 
> Amy Z >>>>>

Okay, I'm with you.  So, Katie is the only real question mark, more 
or less.  Great, thanks for the clarification, Amy.

Kelley