Alicia's age and another picayune thing

[Amy Z]

> Well, if Alicia is a 4th yr when Harry's a 1st, then in GoF when 
he's 
> a 4th, this makes Alicia a 7th.  So, she ~and~ Oliver are gone. 

The passage Rita quoted was from CoS.  So she was a 4th year when 
Harry was a 2nd.

I have another canon question that's really, really picky, so I'm 
putting it here.  Are Stunning and Stupefying Charms the same thing?

In GF I think what is referred to as "Stunning" is spoken "Stupefy!"  
So I thought, OK, the incantation is "Stupefy!" but the name of the 
charm is Stunning.  Simple enough.

Then I noticed that FB mentions "Stupefying Charms" (see sig).  What 
do you think?  Two terms for the same thing?

I said it was picky!  But how else am I going to rival Hermione's 112% 
in Charms?

Amy

----------------------------------------------
 However, it is easy to repulse the Pogrebin 
 with simple hexes or Stupefying Charms.  
 Kicking has also been found effective.
     -Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
----------------------------------------------