[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: Ultimate Unofficial Guide

[Richelle Votaw]

GulPlum wrote:

> Incidentally, and I don't mean to talk down to anyone but I'm 
> curious: do American schools not teach proper use of apostrophes any 
> more? (In particular when to use "it's" -v- "its", and correct usage 
> of "there/their/they're" or "your/you're".) Even in HPFGU I 
> frequently find people who seem to be native speakers who appear 
> never to have been taught the difference. 

I haven't read the book in question (yet, though I suspect I will eventually, if nothing else to entertain myself until OotP is out), but I will jump in to defend my country.  :)  Yes, American schools most definitely teach all of the above.  As early as first grade, I can verify that, I teach it myself.  I can't promise that they learn it, but I do teach it.  I can sympathize with you, though, since as a teacher I notice that sort of thing more than most Americans probably do.  I find it very difficult to have a normal conversation with anyone (online or otherwise) without correcting their grammar.  I frequently bite my tongue to prevent something coming out, I know most adults don't want to be corrected by a first grade teacher.  

Still, we all make mistakes at some time or another, I suppose.  Myself, commas drive me insane.  "They" (whoever "they" are) keep changing the rule about commas and when to use them.  The latest inservice I went to basically says I'm doing it all wrong.  I didn't bother to change, though, since by the time I would get it straight "they" will change it back anyway.

If you see me making major grammatial and punctual errors, you can pass it off to overwork for the day. :)  

Richelle


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]