[HPFGU-OTChatter] Vision of Characters (was: Slash andhomosexuality)

Amanda Geist editor at texas.net
Thu Jan 16 03:47:19 UTC 2003


John said:

> With regard to your Russell Crowe analogy, I'm not so sure it fits. It's
> more like a Food Analogy (I like sausage for X reason). You could probably
> narrow down the reasons you didn't see Russell Crowe as Sirius: his eyes
are
> too beady, etc. Once again, nobody has come up with any reason other than
> "because" for not liking slash.

Um. Why isn't "because" a good enough reason? Isn't personal taste the
dictator here? I'm not trying to be flippant, honest. But it's the same
reason I don't like some foods. Some things taste good and some don't. Don't
ask me *why*; they just work for me or not.

I may not be the most logical person to weigh in because I never read fanfic
anyway. I presume some slash is hot and heavy and some isn't. I wouldn't
like the hot and heavy stuff because I don't like to read hot and heavy sex
stuff. I don't think I'd mind the other. But don't ask me why I don't like
it, or not. It's just my preference. Why does anything more sinister or
judgemental have to be meant or inferred?

~Amanda






More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive