A Clue! (was LOON correction)

ssk7882 <skelkins@attbi.com> skelkins at attbi.com
Fri Jan 31 18:40:12 UTC 2003


"They broke off their conversation about what action Dumbledore 
might be taking, even now, to stop Voldemort only when the lunch 
trolley arrived."

David:
> I hadn't realised until now that there is more than one way to 
> parse this sentence.  Clearly that trolley has greater plot 
> significance than I thought!

Well, we all knew that Dumbledore works in mysterious ways, didn't we?
Little did we know that he was merely biding his time, waiting for 
the prophecied arrival of The Lunch Trolley before he made his move.

Can this be reconciled with MAGICDISHWASHER, do you think?


You know, I once had an English teacher who used to pick out 
sentences like the above whenever they would appear in my essays and 
then demand that I explain to the entire class precisely *why* they 
were grammatically problematic?

Sadistic man, he was.  

Elkins





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive