OOP: SPOILER: Snape

[dumbledore11214]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "cathubodva_raven" 
<wedgeaholic at i...> wrote:
> ...Harry frustrates me at times.  Sometimes he's not very bright.  
> But this is the first time that I have been *really* disappointed 
in 
> him.  Harry has now seen that James was to Snape what (more or 
less) 
> Draco is to Harry, and not the other way around.
> 
> Even if Harry didn't want to walk up to Snape and say: "I feel your 
> pain, why don't we let this be a bonding experience", he should at 
> least have apologised for intruding in Snape's very personal and 
> private memories. In the past, Harry has been *terrified* of being 
> forced to reveal his private thoughts, (feelings for Cho, location 
of 
> Sirius etc) and when he commits that very act of violation, does 
not 
> even apologise.
> 
> Perhaps Harry is like his father in more ways that we have hitherto 
> been led to believe.
> 
> Cathubodva
> (not a Harry-hater, just tired of Snape getting the thin end of the 
> wedge)


I did not get the impression that Harry liked how James and Sirius 
treated Snape, on the contrary wasn't Harry saying that his dad maybe 
was just as arrogant as Snape had been telling him all the time?


I think though that I forgive Harry for deciding to hate Severus yet 
again. I am sure that by the end of the series if they both survive, 
they will resolve their differences.

For now, Harry is too busy blaming Severus for Sirius death and I 
think that part of the blame lies with him too.
Yes, Harry should not have intruded on his memories, but Severus had 
no right  disobeying Dumbledore orders and  ending his lessons with 
Harry, in my opinion. :)


Alla