Oop--naughty words?
melissaworcester
beelissa at nycap.rr.com
Tue Jun 24 13:24:50 UTC 2003
Hi everyone. I'm a relatively new member to the HPforGrownups list,
but the list elves won't let me post this question on that list. I'm
on "no mail" here, I will read responses at the web site since I am
already overwhelmed with too much mail, AND I'm only 1/3 of the way
thru Oop, so I don't have time to chat with you all, though I'm sure
your topics are highly interesting. So, if you respond to this,
please leave the subject line the same so I can find it :-)
There are very, very minor spoilers in this note, but nothing that
gives anything important away.
I'm a mom and am reading Oop to my children. I'm reading ahead, or
trying to. I'm trying to forewarn myself about swear words. I
noticed a few of what I would consider the milder swear words in GoF
and also in the part of Oop that I've read so far (I'm up to the
first Hogsmeade weekend). I was a bit alarmed, though, when I read
Uncle Vernon's words in chapter 2:
"Enough -- effing -- [name of magical item that was particularly
annoying him, deleted in case anyone is worried about spoilers]!"
Does that 2nd word there mean what I think it means, or does it mean
something different in the UK?
Am I going to see more of the same later in the book? Am I going to
see worse (by worse I mean, like the word I think he's hinting at,
but actually spelled out, or the 4-letter word that starts with s,
or Jesus' name in vane -- though, that would be in interesting topic
of conversation based on speculations about the presence or absence
of religion in the wizarding world...)?
I was hoping someone would be able to respond to this message
without giving away major spoilers. I don't mind something
like, "Yes, Harry says such-and-such to Draco after Draco said
something worse to him" but don't tell me Harry says it to Voldemort
after V kills both Ron and Hermione (fake, not a real spoiler, I
haven't read to the end and I don't know who dies yet).
I've often discussed with my boys how an author sometimes uses
swearing to show a person's character -- I mean, how the nasty ones
will swear more than the good ones -- though I know that's not
always true. Or it can show state of mind, Harry swearing at
Hermione would show he was uncharacteristically angry with her,
though I think the point was made very well in the early chapters
without having to resort to that. These ARE supposed to be kids'
books, after all.
Thanks in advance to anyone who takes the time to answer this! :-)
Melissa
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive