The Return of Tom Swift

Amy Z lupinesque at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 11 00:01:34 UTC 2003


June wrote:

> Can't resist this bait, or is it deliberate provocation?  There are 
> a number of people who know my opinions about adverb use 
in dialogue 
> attribution only too well...(did they put you up to this, she asked 
> suspiciously)
> 
> Are you all yawning comfortably?
> 
> THE ONLY WORDS YOU NEED FOR SPEECH ATTRIBUTION 
ARE:
> 
> He/she said
> 
> he/she asked
> 
> No adverbs and no steroids to boost the words:  ie he said, 
she 
> said, they did not jerk out, ejaculate (except in an entirely 
> different genre...), he didn't yell, scream or hiss either.  People 
> say, they don't smirk, giggle or chuckle.  
> 
> Sorry JKR - I hate it.  I only forgive it because it's you and I 
> will tolerate it so I can hang with the likes of Snape, Lupin and 
> the rest of them.  
> 
> So said June, acerbically, and maybe arrogantly

But... but... but if it weren't for adverbs and exotic equivalents of 
"said," we couldn't do Tom Swifties.

she said, amiably.





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive