Found an Odd FLINT in OotP

Amy Z lupinesque at yahoo.com
Sun Aug 29 22:55:46 UTC 2004


B_Boymn:
 
> OK, I see the quote, and I see the connection to Snape, but it is a
> very very thin connection. I still think 'Sirius' should occur in
> place of 'Snape' in the original quote I commented on. 

Ah, but there's a real issue there:  whether Sirius is just doing 
make-work, or is really helping the Order.  The way the passage is 
written, Harry (along with JKR) is judging Snape's sneer unfair.

Amy Z
wondering if she should adopt the ID Jewlovr





More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive