Is Galadriel Waters for real?

[Erin]

Dave 
> One can only imagine that, like the other Galadriel's water, she 
> shows things that never were, or only come true if you are daft 
> enough to pay attention.


Erin:
You know, I liked the first book; the Ultimate Unofficial Guide, but 
the last one (which I got for Christmas) is just plain annoying. Her 
insistence on refering to JKR as "The Lady", her inability to write 
even two pages without telling us how her stupid made-up "clue 
detectors" are wiggling or jumping up and down or wetting themselves 
with excitement, her little running bits which make no sense (JKR 
focuses on eyes? No duh, most authors do, they're called windows to 
the soul for a reason), and her just plain wrong conclusions all 
combine to make the lastest book horribly unreadable for me.  I'll 
read about ten pages with dictionary and OoP in hand, then give up, 
ready to scream in frustration.  

I do see on Mugglenet that the big conclusion this time around is 
that-- there's another basalisk in the Chamber?  Huh?  That is about 
the dumbest thing I ever heard.  We've been there, done that 
already.  Harry killed the first one when he was 12 freakin' years 
old, I doubt another one would offer him much chaalenge.  Heck, now 
that they no what it is, they can just slide a frickin' rooster down 
the tunnel and Harry won't have to fight at all.


Erin