A supposed Hobbit trailer

[Melian]

> PoMrsB (should that be Mrs Thingol?) 
As you wish :) Though I'd rather think that Thingol was Mr. Melian 
than Melian was Mrs. Thingol ;)

> Is that because you think the Silmarillion ought not to be filmed, 
> or because you think Jackson is not the person to do it?
He's not the one to do it, definitely. This is not a LOTR group, so 
not to pursue the subject any longer, let's just say that the 
difference between my vision of Middle-Earth and Mr Jackson's is 
rather significant *mutter*Hit him with a big nice bolt of 
lightning, Eru! Just do it!*mutter*


> For myself, I think the Silmarillion is not very cinematic, but 
then 
> I would have said the same about The Cat in the Hat and The Series 
> of Unfortunate Events.
Myabe ut is not, but it's not impossible to film it. IMNSHO, that 
is :) 

Bye-s
PoMrsB