Mark Evans theory (was Re: JK's Own Site!!!)

[queen_astrofiammante]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "abigailnus" 
<abigailnus at y...> wrote:

> Speaking of this, I'd like to encourage people to vote for this 
question 
> as opposed to the other two (Severus Snape=Perseus Evans and will 
> Sirius return) since I think that by their very inclusion in the 
poll we can 
> gather that the answer to both questions is no.  

The Perseus Evans question is worded so tightly that the answer is 
inevitably no. Is Snape, specifically, Lily's brother? Of course not.

But it would have been worth voting for if it had opened the 
possibility of his being another sort of relative. Perseus Evans is 
one of my favourite of all theories - I just can't see how it can 
possibly be an accident - but I still voted for Mark Evans, as the 
Snape question is worded so as to be worthless. That's why no-one's 
voting for it, (although Perseus Evans has never been the most wildly 
popular chap in fandom).