What's Coming Will Come
justcarol67
justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sat Oct 16 20:30:49 UTC 2004
Griffin782002 wrote:
>
> <snip>
> About the attack to Hogwarts, I think it might not be that far
> fetched. Considering what J.K.R. has said about foreshadowings in the
> P.o.A. movie, I have been thinking about scenes where we could see
> Dementors surrounding the castle. Is it possible that they might
> ordered by L.V. to attack Hogwarts?
Carol responds:
I agree that an attack on Hogwarts is inevitable, but wouldn't it be
anticlimactic to place it in Book 6? That would leave only single
combat between Harry and Voldemort as the climax of Book 7 and the
series as a whole. I think we'll see the war spreading within the WW
outside Hogwarts in Book 6, but no attack on Hogwarts until the end of
Book 7, probably after Dumbledore is dead.
The scene I'm dreading (in Book 7, not 6) is Snape's death--or worse,
a revelation that he's not really on Dumbledore's side. Don't let that
happen, JKR!
For Book 6, I don't want the twins (or one twin) to be killed, but
Molly's boggart and the clock with the hand that points to mortal
peril surely suggests that at least one Weasley will die. I know the
twins are troublemakers sometimes but I like them, especially George.
Carol
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive