* Was Snape at Godric's Hollow? The answer is in HBP!

[gwharrison53]

HI!

NO . . . I don't think that Sanpe was at Godric's

Hollow.    But when he found out that Lord V-----

had killed Lillie, that's when he joined up with

DD, because Sanpe had feelings for her, even ones

that he himself didn't want to face, until she

was dead !

Gail in INd



--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> Please skip this post if you haven't read HBP.
> 
> 
> Karen Barker wrote:
> > > 19) Did Snape actually help LV at Godric's Hollow?  I 
definitely 
> > think he was there and based on the fact that I'm going through 
> > a 'Yes' phase to Q2, I'll say Yes to this too!
> 
> 
> Carol responds:
> This question is definitively answered in "Spinners's End." 
Bellatrix
> demands to know where Snape was when the Dark Lord fell, meaning 
that
> he was *not* at Godric's Hollow or she would not have asked. Snape
> reminds her of what she already knows, that he was sent by the Dark
> Lord to teach at Hogwarts, presumably to fill the vacant (and 
jinxed!)
> DADA position.
> 
> This answer does not lay Bellatrix's doubts to rest--she still
> suspects that Snape is secretly loyal to Dumbledore--but it does
> answer that particular question. Whatever Snape's motives (and I 
think
> Bellatrix is right to suspect him), we know this much:
> 
> Snape could not have helped LV at Godric's Hollow because he wasn't
> there. He was already teaching at Hogwarts.
> 
> Carol, who has much more to say on this question but is trying to 
stay
> with the facts here