Book 6 questions

[cubfanbudwoman]

werebearloony:
> > >  Until further notice I'm saying Crookshanks (half-kneezle), I 
> > > still haven't cone down from the realization that Lupin can't 
> > > be the HBP
 
SSSusan:
> > And why is that?  JKR made a point on her website of saying that 
> > Lupin is half-blood....
 
loony:
> I merely had the realization that Lupin could not possibly be in 
> CoS, where the HBP story originally was.  Even though the story 
> didn't work for CoS I can't see JKR breaking her pattern and 
> introducing the new DADA teacher a whole book early (and Lupin is 
> so vital to PoA that he had to be the DADA teacher there).  So I'm 
> looking for characters who could have been in CoS.
> Just my two pieces of copper
> ~~loony

SSSusan:
Thanks for clarifying, loony.  I see what you're saying, but since 
JKR said there was no *trace* of that storyline still remaining in 
CoS, I still think it's possible that someone not mentioned in that 
book could end up playing into this storyline in book 6.

Siriusly Snapey Susan