No Molly in GoF movie

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Sun Jan 30 06:25:22 UTC 2005


Sherry wrote:
><snip> The Scene before the big Maze test where Harry shows Mrs
Weasley and Bill around and yes I also felt the Hug was one of the
most touching so far.  I had tears running down my face during 
> that scene. Also what about the whole "I want you to meet each
other" from Dumbledoor when he has Serius transform into a person in
front of Snape and Mrs Weasley.  I am bummed.  But then I was looking
forward to the Quidditch cup scene with Archy at the water fountain>
in the Muggle dress stating that he likes a healthy dose of air around
his privates lol.  I cracked up out loud at work when I read that
scene.  And it was just one of those scenes that didn't hit everyone
as funny as it did me.
> 
> 
Another Sherry responded:
> oh, I think the Archie scene is one of the most hilarious in the
whole series.  I too cracked up, laughing aloud.  and I still do every
time I read it!

Carol notes:
I think (hope) they'll keep the scene where Sirius transforms in front
of Snape. They almost *have* to in order to show that Snape didn't
know th Marauders were Animagi (but then they cut so much of that
relationship out of PoA that maybe it doesn't matter). But still,
imagine Rickman!Snape's face when Padfoot transforms into Sirius.
Gotta keep that, and the handshake, too, and Snape sweeping out the
door to go on his mysterious, perilous mission. Sad as I am to see
them leave out Mrs. Weasley, she doesn't absolutely have to be there.
Snape does. 

I don't think Bill will be there, either. (They cut *Percy*, so it's
most unlikely that they'll keep Bill. Which means they also cut one of
my favorite lines, Fred saying, "Shut up, Weatherby" to Percy. I know
it doesn't sound funny out of context, but in the book it cracks me up
every time. The whole running joke with Percy as Weatherby is gone,
along with Percy running out into the water to hug Ron after the
Second Task. Too bad--that side of Percy is badly needed to contrast
with the Percy of OoP. Hope they don't leave *him* out because I'm
sure something important involving him in coming up in HBP.)

BTW, I'm glad that the two previous posters have the same name because
I get confused in attributing posts when the newest comment is at the
top of the message.

Carol, wishing she could be in the theater with SSS to see her
reaction when Hermione gives Harry the hug that should have been Molly's










More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive