OoTP Question/HBP
finwitch
finwitch at yahoo.com
Mon Jul 18 13:34:47 UTC 2005
> Andromeda now:
>
> Another agreement - I thought "Regulus" as soon as I read it --
> seemed a pretty obvious possibility- so I was suprised none of the
> trio thought of him.
Finwitch:
Why should they? Sirius *told* them his brother was killed - on
Voldemort's orders (as Sirius doesn't think Voldemort considered him
worthy to be killed by Voldemort in person...). Why would they consider
Sirius' dead brother to be in his place? Metamorphmagus maybe...
But I have another question - JKR confirmed that the Order does indeed
use Patronuses to deliver messages -- why didn't they teach Harry how
to do that??? The main problem - particularly in the end of OOP was
that Harry hadn't a reliable source of communication at hand - (Rowling
also said that the mirror wouldn't have helped as much as Harry thought
it would have...) and I haven't got my hands on HBP yet, but...
Finwitch
More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter
archive