Advanced Potion Making???

dungrollin spotthedungbeetle at hotmail.com
Tue Mar 8 20:15:04 UTC 2005


Dungrollin wrote:
> > The US version shows Harry and Dumbledore looking into a 
pensieve, Harry with his wand ready. The question is, whose memories 
are in the pensieve? Harry's memories from Godric's Hollow? 

Oh #!@$, this is awful. I'm not going to be able to sleep...
> > 

SSSusan replied:
> One thought I had was that Harry *is* watching the GH memory, and 
the reason I think so is that the light, which appears to be 
emanating from the penseive, is GREEN.  As in, AK-green.
> 
> Good question, though, about whose memories they'd be.  DD's?  
> Snape's? ??
> 
> This wouldn't be pleasant for Harry to see, but wouldn't it be 
> refreshing if, FINALLY, DD allowed Harry to get some real facts?
> 
> SSSusan


Did you have to say that? I'm overexcited as it is... 

However, I've done a U-turn, I now think it's far more likely to be 
some of DD's memories about Voldemort. (This will no doubt change 
regularly over the course of the next day or two.) Something nice 
and bangy... The first three times James and Lily defied him, 
perhaps. Something to explain that cryptic "Knowing him as I have 
done" that annoys me so much.

And I've now convinced myself that the potions book on the adult 
cover is simply a marketing ploy, because they know all the adults 
who see it will immediately think "Snape!" and buy it.

Dungrollin
Wishing she didn't hate herbal tea so much, because she needs 
something to calm her down a bit.









More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive