CoS: Stone Motherless Last?

[M.Clifford]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "blibbering_humdinger"
<blibbering_humdinger at y...> wrote:
> 
> Ron:
> Hi, everyone. I'm new to the group and was thus a little behind 
> the times before I decided to do some "background reading" regarding 
> past threads (don't want to rehash ideas long ago consigned to the 
> murky depths of T-Bay).
> I got the impression that many people consider, unequivocally, 
> CoS to be the worst, or least good, of the HP installments. Why is 
> that so, exactly? For me, personally, I'd put it up there with PoA 
> as the *best* book in the series. (Wooden spoon goes to GoF)
> 
> Just a query.
>  
> Ronald.

That's a shock to me too as I tend to rank COS right up there with my
favourites. But then again I couldn't pick a least favourite of the
series if you used brute force on me. ;D

Welcome to the group Ronald.

Valky