Disappointed with _Chronicles of Narnia_

Dina Lerret bunniqula at gmail.com
Sun May 15 23:58:13 UTC 2005


...Well, sort of.  I was under the initial impression the books would
revolve more around a limited set of characters.  I guess I was
expecting something else.

A gal shared both her HP and Narnia audio books (very nice of her) and
I listened to 1-3 for Narnia yesterday and I'm on the fourth. 
However, the third--I'm going at it chronologically--threw me for a
loop because the central characters were a new batch... *again* (not
forgetting some Arabic-ish folks saying 'jolly good' made me go
WTF'eth - bit disorientating).  On top of this, the narrators keep
changing for each book.

I dunno... I guess I like consistency.  Plus, Harper Audio does this
kind of annoying musical chimes between some chapters.  To sum it up,
I rather like the HP audio books better.  Err, I rather like the HP
books better.  Sorry to the Narnia fans. :-\

Dina




More information about the HPFGU-OTChatter archive