[HPFGU-OTChatter] Rex Reeds Review of GoF - Not Nice

[Heidi]

On 11/21/05, Steve <bboyminn at yahoo.com> wrote:
> Here is a link to Rex Reeds Review of GoF. To say the least, it is a
> scathing review. His opinion is so extreme one wonders if he actually
> saw the movie. It is worth reading though because his review is so
> absurdly extreme as to be almost comical.

Now, I've seen some weird comments - people send emails to some of the
sites I work on saying things like, "How dare they cut out Winky! She
is the key to the whole film!" and "Did they really make Daniel go
underwater to film those scenes?" and "Why did they ignore the entire
plot of the book? Nothing from the book was in the movie!" and "Why
was Voldemort so scary?"

But was Reed paying attention to his popcorn? Harry doesn't get
bruised? The character is barely 14? Moody *becomes* a Death Eater?
There are bodies in EVERY scene?

Wha?

Heidi

http://www.fictionalley.org
FictionAlley - where creativity is magic!