Trashing the films Was Re: GoF movie trailer

[Caius Marcius]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, kemper mentor 
<kempermentor at y...> wrote:
> bumbledore wrote:
> >I for one, hope the GOF puts the magic back into the movies,

How about if we keep the magic on the printed page and let the movie 
moguls do what they will with their Inferius-like adaptations?

>as I thought POA was an insult, and a discusting peice of garbage that 
>should never have been allowed on the silver screen. They should have 
>re-done it.

My feeling is that none of the books should have been cinematically 
rendered at least until all seven books were completed. I also feel an 
animated version - which would have given the story line a greater 
prominence than the SPFX - would have been vastly preferable.

  - CMC (who has not seen Movies One Two and Three, and who will not 
see Movies Four Five Six and Seven)