I could use some help from the experts

[Tonks]

--- In HPFGU-OTChatter at yahoogroups.com, "Jan" <Jan at ...> wrote:
>
> Our family is having a Magical Murder Mystery for our two day 
December get together this year. Christmas at Hogwarts will include 
Dumbledore (who may have been found alive or is being impersonated) 
McGonagall, Pomfrey, Sybill (who needs a good prophesy), Hagrid 
(some deadly new pet?), a new DADA, and 2 students (recovering from 
something). Someone is dead, someone here did it - and facts point 
to everyone. 
> 

Tonks:
Hagrid has some new pet that attached Mrs. Norris.  The pet dies by 
poison.  It really is some rare, but naturally poisonous plant that 
the animal found it the forest, but Hagrid think someone did it.  He 
has a great deal of animosity toward this person. Hagrid suspects 
Filch.  

Filch has angered a few others as well for a variety of reasons. 
(Maybe a detention went bad for the 2 students.) Sort of a `Murder 
on the Orient Express' sort of thing.  Everyone has a motive to want 
the man dead. 

Later Filch has an accident of some sort and it looks like murder, 
but isn't.  Everyone thinks that someone else did it, and they all 
ponder to themselves the motives the others had.  A few band 
together here and there, maybe a love interest, and they share their 
thoughts with the other person. A couple or two plot to get the real 
killer to confess. 

Maybe some Draught of Living Death comes into play. Maybe Filch 
isn't really dead. 

Oh, I am out on a limb here at 2:00am. I will have to think more 
about this
  have to go to bed now.

Tonks_op  
Zzzzzzzz