The Agony and the Ecstacy

[dumbledore11214]

> Alla:
> > After all people who are dissapointed spent many years as well 
> analysing the books, awaiting with the baited breath how the story 
> ends, I feel it is their right as readers to have their say and I 
> certainly find some things to criticise, BUT am I changing my 
opinion
> of the worth of the book as a whole?
> 
> Carol:
> Well, you're the List Elf. But I'm as tired of all the bickering as
> Harry is when Ron and Hermione are fussing about--oops. If you 
haven't
> read the book, you'll just have to find out, won't you?
> > 
> Alla:
> > Nope, I think it is a fascinating story, with all plot holes and 
> awkwardness in it.
><SNIP>


Alla:

Cutting pretty much everything else to reiterate one point - I am 
posting as a **list member** not an elf and stating my position as a 
list member.

And my position would be that everybody has a right to criticise any 
aspect of the book in **any** tone, as long as this tone is not 
directed at the other list member.

I do not agree with you Carol on that aspect at all.

I was talking about **my** positive experiences only.


Alla.