[HPFGU-OTChatter] Re: NY Times article: Memo to the Dept. of Magical Copyright Enforcement

[Julie Borgmann]

My knockoff coach bag/wallet and louis vuitton sunglasses all look authentic (gifts from my mom).  I work with people who love these kinds of things (why on earth would someone spend 500 on a purse to only carry 20 bucks in?)  not that I'd ever buy any of this myself mind you - I'm more of a target clearance shopper.  I wonder how lack of knock offs would affect prices of the real thing - would the real thing be less valuable (because no one's trying to copy it) or more so because its more rare?

Lee Kaiwen <leekaiwen at yahoo.com> wrote:          stacygalore blessed us with this gem On 11/08/2007 12:12:

> ITA. It is like my fake Prada bag. Nobody is expected to believe 
> that a real Prada bag is being sold on the streets of Chinatown.

Well, since I don't know "Prada" from "Pravda", I'll take your word on that.

In Asia it's easy to find knock-offs of all calibers, from the $1 DVDs 
on the streets to high end electronics. I've seen JVC and Sony 
knock-offs in Hong Kong that you couldn't (and aren't supposed to) tell 
from the real thing; then again, I've seen $US10 knocck-offs in night 
markets that people buy BECAUSE they're fake.

> Yes, I agree. I went to Manila two years ago just as the big 
> crackdown on pirate dvd sales was happening, yet there were still
> guys on the street offering them.

Without meaning to be cynical, WHICH "big crackdown" was that? If the 
Phllipines is anything like China, every year or so the governent will 
make a big show, capture and destroy a few million DVDs, then it's back 
to business as usual. The problem is, knock-offs and pirated DVDs are a 
big part of the economic equation -- there are entire towns in China 
whose sole product is pirated DVDs. Put the pirates out of business, and 
you destroy the local economy.

Of course, it doesn't help when a genuine copy of Windows Vista sells 
for the equivalent of three months' wages in Beijing. I don't know what 
your income is, but what American would pay 6 to 8 thousand dollars for 
Vista when you can pick it up on the street for a buck?

Lee Kaiwen, Taiwan


         


              Have you donated blood lately?
  A child like mine may need it!
  Mom to Kaleigh age 6
  in remission for aplastic anemia 1 year!!!
  www.aamds.org                                  
  Also proud mama to two very active healthy boys:
  Ryan almost 9 and Tyler pushin 3








       
---------------------------------
Got a little couch potato? 
Check out fun summer activities for kids.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]